秋田预测市场 · Discord 审计

Kalshi 止损功能缺失引发用户需求与限价卖混淆

2026-07-12 · Kalshi · 38 条相关讨论

ocean 2026-07-11 21:46:13

Is Kalshi ever planning to add stop losses to Predictions?

Is Kalshi ever planning to add stop losses to Predictions?

pup 2026-07-11 22:59:56

They already have it it’s a sell limit

They already have it it’s a sell limit

ocean 2026-07-11 23:56:33

It's not the same thing

It's not the same thing

ocean 2026-07-12 00:01:02

If I bought a contract at 30c, and it rises to 60c, and I set a sell limit to 45c, it'll just sell the contract immediately instead of triggering at 45c

If I bought a contract at 30c, and it rises to 60c, and I set a sell limit to 45c, it'll just sell the contract immediately instead of triggering at 45c

Awwndrei 2026-07-12 00:03:31

It is the same thing what

It is the same thing what

Awwndrei 2026-07-12 00:03:39

You're not selling it correctly

You're not selling it correctly

Awwndrei 2026-07-12 00:03:45

Double check what you're doing

Double check what you're doing

ocean 2026-07-12 00:04:03

I just tested it

I just tested it

ocean 2026-07-12 00:04:25

That's literally what a sell limit is. Triggering at the same price or better ofc it's gonna act this way

That's literally what a sell limit is. Triggering at the same price or better ofc it's gonna act this way

ocean 2026-07-12 00:06:18

bruh

bruh

Awwndrei 2026-07-12 00:06:39

Lemme think about it

Lemme think about it

Awwndrei 2026-07-12 00:07:57

Yeah I don't think there's a way to do that

Yeah I don't think there's a way to do that

ocean 2026-07-12 00:14:39

Yeah that's what I'm saying, it'd be real useful

Yeah that's what I'm saying, it'd be real useful

ocean 2026-07-12 00:14:57

But it probably is because they'd make less money. Letting you guarantee profits

But it probably is because they'd make less money. Letting you guarantee profits

Awwndrei 2026-07-12 00:17:57

A stop loss has no guarantee of you generating profit

A stop loss has no guarantee of you generating profit

Awwndrei 2026-07-12 00:19:45

Would be an interesting feature but wouldn't be as effective for regular traders as you might think

Would be an interesting feature but wouldn't be as effective for regular traders as you might think

ocean 2026-07-12 00:20:37

True, i've been scalping the BTC 15 minute so it'd be insane there

True, i've been scalping the BTC 15 minute so it'd be insane there

ocean 2026-07-12 00:23:34

doesn't know what a sell limit is, doesn't know what hyperbole is

doesn't know what a sell limit is, doesn't know what hyperbole is

ocean 2026-07-12 00:23:36

gg alright bro

gg alright bro

garza0.5 2026-07-12 01:23:20

it has a guarantee of breaking even where you got in at bud its not hard to read the lines that thats what hes trying to say hes not saying guaranteed profit hes making sure no risk is being taken

it has a guarantee of breaking even where you got in at bud its not hard to read the lines that thats what hes trying to say hes not saying guaranteed profit hes making sure no risk is being taken

ѕησωу∂яαgση 2026-07-12 01:26:19

depending on the market, u could get screwed by slippage, no?

depending on the market, u could get screwed by slippage, no?

garza0.5 2026-07-12 01:26:29

buddy what howre u gonna tell me when i do it on robinhood all the time

buddy what howre u gonna tell me when i do it on robinhood all the time

garza0.5 2026-07-12 01:26:37

it might slip a cent or two nothing drastic fam

it might slip a cent or two nothing drastic fam

garza0.5 2026-07-12 01:26:44

its automated

its automated

ѕησωу∂яαgση 2026-07-12 01:32:39

imagine someone's holding 2.5k shares for this w/ a stop loss. stop loss hits, 1k gets sold off at 85, other 1.5k gets sold off at 3c. whoop de doo, they got screwed

imagine someone's holding 2.5k shares for this w/ a stop loss. stop loss hits, 1k gets sold off at 85, other 1.5k gets sold off at 3c. whoop de doo, they got screwed

garza0.5 2026-07-12 01:36:07

thanks for the heads up, & honestly i believe that, ive just never encountered cuz ive never been the one to buy 2.5k shares but hopefully someday.

thanks for the heads up, & honestly i believe that, ive just never encountered cuz ive never been the one to buy 2.5k shares but hopefully someday.

ѕησωу∂яαgση 2026-07-12 01:36:34

well, i was just using the 2.5k number as an example that can be applied to the ss

well, i was just using the 2.5k number as an example that can be applied to the ss

garza0.5 2026-07-12 01:36:37

Lets say i have two seperate orders, instead of just 1 it will still be the same issue because theres not enough buyers right

Lets say i have two seperate orders, instead of just 1 it will still be the same issue because theres not enough buyers right

ѕησωу∂яαgση 2026-07-12 01:36:51

it can be smth like 10 shares, a block is down at 3c and there's 0.01 share at 75c or smth hypothetically

it can be smth like 10 shares, a block is down at 3c and there's 0.01 share at 75c or smth hypothetically

ѕησωу∂яαgση 2026-07-12 01:37:20

im not sure wut u mean by 2 separate orders tbh

im not sure wut u mean by 2 separate orders tbh

ѕησωу∂яαgση 2026-07-12 01:37:48

the total amt of shares ur trying to sell off is still the same tho, no?

the total amt of shares ur trying to sell off is still the same tho, no?

ѕησωу∂яαgση 2026-07-12 01:38:22

so if there's bad liquidity, then i dont c how having 2 separate orders would affect things?

so if there's bad liquidity, then i dont c how having 2 separate orders would affect things?

garza0.5 2026-07-12 03:01:33

im pretty sure kalshi lets us know when we place the slip beforehand if there is high slippage

im pretty sure kalshi lets us know when we place the slip beforehand if there is high slippage

ѕησωу∂яαgση 2026-07-12 04:34:23

i mean ... there can b no slippage when u place, but high slippage when u sell out

i mean ... there can b no slippage when u place, but high slippage when u sell out